Skip to content

Proposal: Introducing FastExcel Benchmark Performance Testing Module #572

@GOODBOY008

Description

@GOODBOY008

Proposal: Introducing FastExcel Benchmark Performance Testing Module

Background & Project Positioning

FastExcel is positioned as a high-performance Java tool for Excel file processing, with core value propositions:

  • High Performance: Significantly reduced memory consumption compared to traditional Excel processing libraries
  • Stream Operations: Memory-friendly processing for large-scale data (millions of rows)
  • Simplicity: Intuitive API design for easy integration

However, as the project evolves and user base grows, we face several challenges:

  1. Lack of Quantified Performance Validation: While we claim FastExcel outperforms traditional libraries (e.g., Apache POI), we lack systematic benchmark data to support these claims
  2. Increasing Regression Risk: Each code change may impact performance, but we currently lack automated performance monitoring mechanisms
  3. Insufficient User Scenario Coverage: Cannot ensure performance across various data scales and usage scenarios
  4. Difficult Competitive Assessment: Lack of objective performance comparison data with similar products

Necessity of Benchmark Module

1. Validate Core Value Proposition

  • Verify FastExcel's performance advantages over Apache POI through scientific microbenchmarks
  • Provide quantified memory efficiency data to support "significantly reduced memory consumption" claims
  • Establish performance baselines to provide users with reliable performance expectations

2. Ensure Development Quality

  • Provide data-driven decision support for code optimization
  • Establish historical tracking of performance evolution
  • Enable systematic performance analysis across different scenarios

3. Enhance User Confidence

  • Provide transparent performance test reports to build user trust
  • Offer objective performance comparison data for user selection decisions
  • Demonstrate best practices and performance across different scenarios

Technical Solution Design

Key Test Scenario Design

  1. Microbenchmarks

    • Data converter performance
    • Event processing chain efficiency
    • Memory allocation pattern analysis
  2. Large Data Scenario Testing

    Data Scale: SMALL(1K) → MEDIUM(10K) → LARGE(100K) → EXTRA_LARGE(1M+)
    File Formats: XLSX, XLS, CSV
    Operation Types: Read, Write, Fill, Streaming
    
  3. Memory Efficiency Specialized Testing

    • Streaming read memory usage patterns
    • Bulk write memory growth curves
    • GC pressure analysis
  4. Comparative Benchmarks

    • FastExcel vs Apache POI performance comparison
    • Memory usage efficiency comparison
    • Performance across different data scales

Implementation Status

The benchmark module has been fully implemented with the following components:

  • JMH Integration: Complete Maven configuration with JMH dependencies
  • Comprehensive Test Suites: Comparison benchmarks, memory efficiency tests, streaming benchmarks
  • Automated Execution: Multi-profile support with configurable dataset sizes
  • Advanced Features: Interactive CLI, memory profiling, reports

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions